Who is the greatest NFL player to never win a Super Bowl?


Dec 29, 2009
My dad asked me this and I thought it was a very interesting question. Its probably a matter of opinion but I'd probably go with Barry Sanders.
Barry Sanders it is, sir.

I can't think of another player that's
greater that has NOT won a Super Bowl.

Barry was like Karl Malone of the NBA...
Routinely one of the top 3 offensive
producers in the league, but just cannot
get that big game done.

To add others....

Andre Reed and Tim Brown.

Both great players but NO titles.